Ice Cream Creativity

Operators scoop up sales with intriguing frozen desserts.

By 
Pamela Parseghian, Contributing Food Writer

Sallie Mae’s cookie bowl sundae.

Brigham Young University, in Provo, Utah, produces 185,000 gallons of ice cream a year. Standard flavors like vanilla, cookies and cream and cookie dough sell best, but staff at the university creamery aren’t afraid to create their own, more adventurous flavors, such as a spicy apple pie version.

The off-beat treat, combining the flavors of apple pie and hot peppers, went over surprisingly well, says foodservice director, Dean Wright. “It had the sweetness of the apple, but as you swallowed you got that heat from the hot pepper,” he says. “We have a rotation of about 36 flavors,” Wright explains.

The school’s recipe book includes some 200 ice cream formulas that have been offered since the university started producing its own ice cream in 1948. One flavor, Scottish oatmeal with caramel, was developed to honor poet Robert Burns. Mint brownie is one of BYU’s newest frozen concoctions. The rendition, which features pieces of brownie and chocolate, is already a top seller.

Wright says that the university’s ice cream is so loved by its students that dining services ships it all over the country to alumni. In addition, during televised football and basketball games, the school conducts a trivia contest and winners are sent BYU ice cream as a prize. “Our ice cream is something that the university is proud of,” Wright notes.

BYU sells its ice cream in its two residence hall cafeterias, at the school’s four convenience stores and in one grocery store. Several off-campus restaurants, including a pizzeria, also serve the school’s ice cream.

Stellar ice cream: At the University of Maryland in College Park, the newest specialty ice cream flavor is Star Spangled Explosion, which is available for the next two years. Dining Services developed the flavor to commemorate the 200th anniversary of the War of 1812, says Dining Services’ executive pastry chef, Jeff Russo.

The new ice cream has a strawberry base with a bit of sherry; red, white and blue sprinkles; and “oversized malted milk balls to represent cannon balls, which bombarded Fort McHenry as Francis Scott Key wrote the ‘Star Spangled Banner’ in 1814,” Russo says. “Strawberry was picked for the ice cream base because there is historic documentation that Dolly Madison served strawberry ice cream at her husband, James Madison’s, presidential inauguration in 1813.”

The university has been making ice cream for 88 years, and Dining Services took over production eight years ago. A local co-op dairy farm prepares the base.

“Our ice cream is sold in the dining halls, The Dairy at Turner Hall and our convenience stores,” he adds. “We produce 10,000 gallons a year of small-batch, hand-crafted ice cream.”

By “hand-crafted” Russo means, “we actually do all the folding and blending in of flavors and particulates by hand, rather than pouring everything into a hopper.” Folding by hand gives an even distribution of additional flavors and treats, Russo explains.

For a Vani-Loh Mango ice cream that was developed for UMD’s President, Dr. Wallace Loh, vanilla bean and mango ice cream are swirled together with a hint of dark rum. “Our newest sport flavor is Rockin’ Randy, which is named in honor of football coach Randy Edsall,” Russo says. “Coach Edsall informed us of the flavors he prefers”—vanilla chocolate chip ice cream with chocolate marble swirl—so Russo took those and added Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and Heath Bar pieces.

Baked goods: At the Sallie Mae call center in Newark, Del., a Eurest account, Chef/Manager Brent Hanni finds success pairing cookies and ice cream by turning cookies into cups to hold the frozen treat. For the cup, Hanni places two ounces of cookie dough on the underside of muffin tins that have been sprayed with oil. He bakes the cups—with the muffin tins upside down—at 325°F for about 11 minutes. As the dough bakes, it slips down the tins to form the cups.

After cooling for at least 11 minutes, Hanni twists the cookie cups off the pan and fills them with ice cream and requested toppings, such as sauces and whipped cream. At Sallie Mae there is no seating area, so the cookie cup can make eating ice cream at employees’ desks a neater experience.

The cookie bowl sundae also is a great marketing tool, drawing people into the servery. “As soon as one person is seen with it,” Hanni explains, “more people show up.”

At Oracle in Redwood Shores, Calif., Ian Farrell, executive pastry chef for Bon Appétit, also serves ice cream with baked goods. He makes whoopee pie sandwiches by stuffing ice cream between mini cakes. Farrell typically serves the frozen sandwiches at catered events. Farrell and his team assemble the desserts to order so diners can pick from a variety of whoopee pie renditions, such as snicker doodle, mint, peanut butter or chocolate, as well as choose from a few ice cream flavors. Then guests can add extras, such as ganache or seasonal berries.

Whoopee pies work better than cookies for a sandwich because “a softer whoopee pie doesn’t offer as much resistance when biting into it,” Farrell says.

At Golden Valley Memorial Hospital, in Clinton, Mo., ice cream is used to celebrate staff appreciation weeks. “Twice, during hospital/nurses week, we celebrate with free make-your-own sundaes for all staff on all shifts,” says Director of Food & Nutrition Services Cynthia Barron Brouk. Management staff scoop the ice cream for the employees being honored at the event.

“July is national ice cream month, so we featured different novelties,” Brouk says. This year’s celebration included a miniature purple ice cream truck that staffers, with the help of friends, built and wheeled around the hospital ringing a bell and delivering frozen treats, rather than waiting for employees to come to the cafeteria.

The truck was popular, says Karen Elmer, the hospital’s production manager. In fact, hospital workers called the kitchen requesting more deliveries. “It was overwhelming at first,” Elmer says. “We sold the whole case on the first day.” 

More From FoodService Director

Ideas and Innovation
food snap

We started a 50-member vegan team in response to students expressing the need for more vegan options. Between our monthly meetings, students are asked to take photos of foods they eat in and out of the dining halls to give us a true picture of the kinds of things they like and the kinds of foods that cause disappointment. This exercise has sparked a lot of conversation and given us more insight into what we could do better.

Ideas and Innovation
hybrid worker

Some of our employees can work four 10-hour days. It’s really helped with balance. We’ve also created a lot of hybrid positions, such as a personal services assistant and foodservice worker role. It allows workers to pick up more shifts and cover both positions.

Ideas and Innovation
cheeseburger

We set up an interactive collaboration with our dietetics department where students worked with our culinary team to test how recipes are imagined and produced. One of the recipes they came up with was a barbecue tempeh sandwich, which they believed was a great option for vegan students across campus. We added the sandwich to our On the Go program and then expanded it to our vegan station on campus due to its success.

Ideas and Innovation
salad bowl

We have reorganized our salad bars to not only include the traditional DIY salad ingredients, but also several daily entree salads. Our students requested 32-ounce heavy glass salad bowls that have been wildly popular. The big bowls allow students to load up on their favorite salads and customize with additional ingredients from around the servery. We have seen a significant surge in usage that cuts across all groups, including athletes.

FSD Resources