Hovering in the Background

With food tampering becoming an ever-present threat, operators need to be aware of every possible way to prevent problems. One tactic many may not have thought of is screening potential hires. Doing so allows operators to potentially find people who may have a history of behavior that could impact the safety of employees and customers.

In recent years, reports of food tampering have ranged from packaged meat and beverage contamination in retail settings to deliberate acts of meal spoilage in foodservice. It’s these sorts of incidences that could cause foodservice operators to be afraid. To be very afraid.

Fortunately, while it’s not possible to eliminate the potential for such threats entirely, it’s becoming increasingly necessary to try—and conducting background checks on potential hires is an effective tool toward achieving that goal.

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recommends that retail food store and foodservice establishment operators consider, among other things, employee screening—before, at and after hiring. The federal agency urges employers to examine the background of “all staff (including seasonal, temporary, contract and volunteer staff, whether hired directly or through a recruitment firm) as appropriate to their position, considering candidates’ access to sensitive areas of the facility and the degree to which they will be supervised and other relevant factors.”

The FDA advises operators to:

  • Obtain and verify work references, addresses and phone numbers.
  • Participate in one of the pilot programs managed by the Immigration and Naturalization Service and the Social Security Administration.
  • Have local law enforcement or a contract service provider perform criminal background checks when necessary.

Screening should, FDA adds, “be applied equally to all staff, regardless of race, national origin, religion, and citizenship or immigration status.”

Fact checkers: Employers have the right to conduct criminal background checks in-house, yet many prefer to hire outside experts to handle the task. One caveat: the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires an employer to obtain written authorization from a job applicant to do a credit or background check if an outside company will be doing it.

Beyond that, if the applicant is not hired, the employer has an obligation to tell him the reason, and to reveal the name and address of the service that furnished the information.

“We do drug checks for all general employees,” says Judy Lucas, spokeswoman for Buffalo, N.Y.–based Delaware North Cos. “For management, we do background, financial and criminal checks.” The firm, whose divisions include Sportservice, Travel Hospitality Services and Parks & Resorts, contracts with The Carco Group Inc., an investigative and security consulting practice based in Holtsville, N.Y.

“Basically you’re trying to find the folks who have a history of behavior that could negatively impact the safety of employees and customers,” says Jerry Castoral, Carco Group’s vice president of sales and marketing.

Such background checks are likely to unearth relevant details about past activity, but they don’t guarantee an employee won’t eventually do something harmful. “There is nothing to prevent someone from snapping one day and deciding to do something bad,” says Castoral. “The terrorists of 9/11 were the perfect example. If you did a background check (on them) you wouldn’t have found anything derogatory. But the idea is to find someone who might not be a good fit for the organization.”

Calling in experts: Most large organizations will outsource employee background checks to a third party “just because it’s an intricate type of process,” Castoral explains.

In the beginning, companies simply asked for references. “That was a precursor to formal background screening through third parties,” says Castoral. Today, the variety of reports that can be done creates a mosaic of information about prospective employees. Says Castoral, “It’s not a single component you’re looking at. You’re taking into account the actual interview, the prior experience, the background checks, prior tendencies…all those components put together help to draw a picture of that person.”

There is no shortage of firms to hire. “The first thing you want to ask about is compliance,” suggests Kevin Prendergast, president of Research Associates Inc. in Cleveland. “Do they understand the privacy laws and issues that regulate the industry, both on the national and state-by-state level? There are different state laws, there is the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and there are a whole bunch of issues out there that, if you don’t get them right, will cause you problems.”

Operators should also check the firm’s own references. “People can tell you anything,” Prendergast points out. “They’ll tell you their turnaround time is four days, and then half the time you get your results in 10 or 12 days. Are they able to deliver what they say? The best people to tell you that are their existing clients.”

Tread carefully: Pre-employment inquiries can prove a legal nightmare for employers who act first and think later. Many federal and state laws protect applicants from impermissible inquiries. These generally have no bearing on his or her ability to perform the essential functions of the position for which they are being considered.

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) cautions that pre-employment inquiries concerning an applicant’s age, race, color, religion, national origin or disability may be regarded as evidence of discrimination.

Pre-employment inquiries are considered discriminatory if they satisfy the following two-prong test: The inquiry tends to affect members of a protected class differently than it does other applicants; and the inquiry is not justified by a bona fide occupational qualification or business-related job necessity.   

More From FoodService Director

Industry News & Opinion

Noncommercial foodservice operations and other employers would be spared from costly new overtime pay regulations if 21 states succeed in the legal challenge they jointly filed yesterday.

The lawsuit asks the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas to set aside the rules, which are scheduled to take effect on Dec. 1.

If the court rejects the request, restaurants and other businesses will be required after that date to pay overtime to any salaried employee who works more than 40 hours in a week and earns less than $47,476 on an annual basis.

The...

Industry News & Opinion

The new unpaid-balance policy at Canon-McMillan School District in Pittsburgh is making waves after a former cafeteria worker sounded off about the practice on social media.

Stacy Koltiska said she quit her job with the district after being forced to take hot meals away from students who owed lunch money, CBS News reports .

Under a new policy that was implemented at Canon-McMillan this year, students whose lunch debt exceeds $25 are not allowed to receive a hot lunch. Children in grades K-6 are given a sandwich in its place, and older students receive no lunch. A recent...

Industry News & Opinion

Due to low participation in its lunch program, Talawanda School District in Oxford, Ohio, is raising the price of school meals this year, Patch.com reports .

The cost of school lunches will see a 30-cent increase, half of which is being enacted to cover the district’s budget. The other half is being required by the government to cover the cost of free and reduced-price lunches provided to low-income families. Prior to this year, the district had not raised prices since 2009.

The district’s cafeterias have experienced a decline in student participation since implementing the...

Industry News & Opinion

Six Philadelphia hospitals were honored by the city’s department of public health for healthy food initiatives introduced as part of the local Good Food, Healthy Hospitals program, bizjournals.com reports .

The hospitals each debuted healthy measures to their dining services, such as lowering the cost of water bottles and seltzers, and offering dishes that incorporate local produce. One hospital was also honored for operating its own organic farm.

The facilities that were honored were:

Einstein Medical Center Philadelphia Cancer Treatment Centers of America’s Eastern...

FSD Resources